Skip to content
Interface language: English
Imperium / Signal

What does the customer compare your service with? The category changes the conversation

Understand which alternatives customers actually compare and align a service category with the work offered.

Article language: English

A woman beside three circular pieces mounted on a supported axle.
In this article

Imagine a studio that organises equipment manufacturers' offers and designs catalogues for them. It receives a price enquiry for a thousand copies. The customer already has a file and wants it printed. The studio starts talking about product hierarchy, content work and collection consistency. Both sides say “catalogue”. Only one intends to develop it further.

In this fictional conversation the problem arose before the quote. The customer put the service in the category of a printer. The studio sees itself as a partner preparing how an offer is presented. Before defending the value of its work, it should establish whether the customer needs that work at all. Perhaps the comparison is wrong. Perhaps the comparison is right but the enquiry has reached the wrong address.

A printer may be the right answer

Start with a possibility uncomfortable for the seller: the customer has organised material, an approved design and needs physical copies. A question about quantity, finishing and timing makes sense. There is no need to tell them they must buy an elaborate design process to deserve work with a more ambitious company. They need someone to perform the task that actually remains.

Another customer may be in a very different situation. They have product photographs and many inconsistent descriptions. They do not yet know what belongs in the catalogue or how a recipient should recognise the right collection. If they also ask about printing, the category name may have hidden earlier work. First establish where the idea to order came from, rather than immediately correcting the customer's vocabulary.

This is the difference between a supplier category and the buyer's task. A category is shorthand that helps people understand what to expect from an offer and what to compare it with. It need not exactly mirror the company's organisation, but it should lead to reasonable expectations. If the studio is read as a place to order printing, the recipient may omit questions the studio considers most important.

The owner should therefore gather information about reasons for contact. Did the customer find photographs of finished catalogues? Were they told to prepare material? Did someone pass on the address saying “they make catalogues”? Each route could explain the comparison. The number of similar enquiries alone does not show that the price or the whole business must change.

Discuss service price, costs and value (in Polish) only against an identified scope. The earlier decision here is which customer situation the company wants its offer to address. The studio can deliberately handle catalogue development, printing alone or both. Each choice requires a matching way of working, not merely a new name.

Follow two orders from the same fictional manufacturer. First it launches a new collection and needs its presentation developed. Once that work is complete, it returns for another print run of the existing catalogue. The company, contact person and product group may be unchanged. The reason for buying and appropriate service scope have changed. The studio should not automatically sell the earlier work again if only physical copies are now needed.

The same customer may later return with an expanded collection needing new development. Then the scope must be identified from the new situation. Belonging to the group “equipment manufacturers” helps find recipients but does not establish what they are ordering now. When choosing a service category, identify the event creating the need too: a collection being created or reworked, rather than every action connected with its catalogue.

This has an organisational consequence for the studio. It can maintain the relationship while directing the customer to an appropriate route for reprinting. It can also deliberately add production management to its own business. Either way the owner makes a concrete decision about work accepted. Wanting to retain the customer does not itself define what the company will perform.

A company's competitors and a customer's alternatives are not the same list

In a 28 December 2020 article, April Dunford suggests considering the customer's actual alternatives, including their existing way of doing the task. She distinguishes these from companies a seller sees as competitors even though the buyer does not consider them. This is her approach to positioning: defining how an offer should be understood against available alternatives.

The studio may know five other practices with similar portfolios. The customer, however, may be deciding whether to outsource development, give the material to its own designer or keep the existing catalogue until next season. The studio's list describes a market of providers. The customer's list describes the decision now facing them. The conversation needs the latter, confirmed in the specific situation.

Do not build that list by suggesting answers. “Are you considering other agencies?” steers the conversation toward the category chosen by the studio. Better reconstruct what the company tried to do with the material and what it is considering now. It may already have a designer but lack confirmed product data. It may have data and need production alone. Either finding changes what help means.

Keep the option of leaving things unchanged too. In our fictional example the manufacturer may send the older catalogue with an updated list of new items. That concrete way of working has advantages and inconveniences. The studio should learn why a change is being considered. It need not attribute catastrophic consequences to current practice to justify its own service.

The owner can then decide which comparison to enter. If the studio specialises in developing the presentation of a complex collection, it can address companies with that task. That does not make it superior to a printer. It means choosing the work the company will do and the situation where that work is needed.

Aeneia conceptual photography

A category name opens questions but does not do the work

In the abstract of Mita Sujan and James Bettman's 1989 research, the authors describe four studies linking perceived brand distinctiveness to position in a product category. They distinguish a brand perceived as a separate niche from a different proposition within a broader category. The studies concern perceptions of consumer brands.

The studio must decide whether to use a service category familiar to customers or propose another term for its scope. Renaming itself a “product experience laboratory” may remove an association with printing while leaving customers unable to picture what they are buying. Avoiding the wrong comparison does not itself create the right one. The recipient should still be able to name the work, its result and their own contribution.

Suppose the studio chooses “developing catalogues for complex collections”. In our example the name draws attention to work before printing. It must then check whether its business matches that promise: can it work with product information, and is that the scope it wants to accept?

The Institute for Strategy and Competitiveness at Harvard Business School connects a value proposition with choices about customers, needs and relative price. It presents this as a part of strategy linked to the company's activities. This is a useful framework for checking whether a promise to a buyer matches how the service is actually delivered.

For our studio the category choice may lead to a different start to cooperation. When the customer supplies a finished file, the company works within one scope. If the collection must be understood and material organised together, both teams need different skills and time. A new name will not create them for the next enquiry, even in exceptionally careful typography.

The company can also deliberately retain several scopes. It must then decide what forms the core service and what is a separate extension. Modular service and limits to customisation (in Polish) develops that organisational decision. The category should help people recognise the division rather than hide everything under a promise to do any material from beginning to end.

Find where the wrong comparison comes from

Our studio may discover that most visible projects show stacks of finished catalogues. Information about work on their content appears only in conversation. The customer therefore has a reason to ask about printing. This is a hypothetical cause to investigate. The company's material may simply have highlighted a different stage from the service sold.

A referral is another possible cause. A recipient hears “they prepared our catalogue” and fills in the meaning. The referrer may mean development while the contacting company means production of copies. Reconstruct what task was communicated. A new market category need not be invented if clarifying the existing name and the situation in which cooperation begins is enough.

The studio may also find that it mainly reaches customers whose need is already outside its chosen scope. Rewriting the description alone will not resolve that. The owner should decide whether to change the work accepted, the route by which enquiries are obtained, or both. Do not promise a broader service simply so no enquiry looks lost.

When deciding whether to prepare an offer (in Polish), use a concrete description of the need. If the customer really wants printing and not content development, the studio can recognise that without writing an elaborate design proposal. If the customer needs earlier help, the first conversation should cover that earlier stage.

Also agree how the service is described inside the company. The person receiving a message and the person preparing the design should describe the same scope. If the first accepts every catalogue-related task and the second expects work on the whole collection, the problem returns during delivery. An agreed category should help both qualify the case, not just look good in a website heading.

From a business decision to an offer description

Before commissioning new copy, the company should be able to state its own choice. For the fictional studio it might be: we work with manufacturers who have a collection and need its catalogue presentation developed; they arrange production of copies separately. This scope identifies both when the work begins and where it ends.

Only then does the task of writing a service-page description (in Polish) arise. The description should show the situation, result and starting conditions. It should not invent a company that would first have to be built to deliver its promise. In our example, the important thing is explaining work before printing, not adding another adjective to “comprehensive”.

If the company retains two different scopes, it may also need a comparison of two services on its website (in Polish). That is a separate information-design task. First, however, the owner must confirm that both are actually offered and which situations they suit. Symmetrical columns cannot make the decision for them.

After changing the description, check how recipients describe their reasons for contact. Do they still ask only about print quantity? Can they say what work they want before printing? One accurate conversation does not prove the effectiveness of the whole positioning. It may indicate that one person understood the particular scope, allowing the enquiry to be qualified without starting again.

At Aeneia Design, the selected offer context can be discussed as the basis for a website’s structure and content. The project scope needs agreement. A clear description may help the studio recognise whether a later enquiry about a thousand copies concerns its service, an earlier stage needing clarification or an order for another provider.

Aeneia / Aeneia editorial

Editorial article. Source links are included in the text.

About Aeneia

Brands we have worked with

  • L’Oréal
  • Garnier
  • Netflix
  • Carrefour
  • Warner Bros. Discovery
  • Biedronka
  • HBO Max
  • Wolt
  • Żabka
  • COSRX
  • Embassy of China in Poland
  • Mixa
Aeneia / Initium

From knowledge to a decision

Tell us what you want to put in order. We will agree on where to start.

Contact Aeneia

We partner with and use solutions from:

  • Google
  • OpenAI
  • Microsoft
  • Stripe
  • Anthropic
  • Linear